Rum

Painkiller

Name: Painkiller
Yield: 1 servings

Glass: Double Old-Fashioned

The Soggy Dollar Bar's beachfront BVI standard, navy rum, pineapple, cream of coconut, and orange.

rum tiki tropical caribbean shaken pineapple coconut

Ingredients

fresh pineapple juice (4 oz)
fresh orange juice (1 oz)
cream of coconut (1 oz)
Pusser's Navy rum (2 oz)
nutmeg (1 pinch)
orange wheel (1)
maraschino cherry (1)

Daphne Henderson never shared her original Soggy Dollar recipe; Pusser's founder Charles Tobias reverse-engineered the 4-1-1-1 ratio that became the canonical spec and trademarked the name.¹^,² Some sources also credit George and Marie Myrick (previous Soggy Dollar owners), and the original drink may have been built on Cruzan rum before Pusser's secured the trademark.³

Brand recommendations. Best: Pusser's Navy Rum (trademark-bound for the official spec, Pusser's Gunpowder Proof 54.5% gives the richest result, regular Pusser's Blue Label 42% is the standard pour); Coco López cream of coconut; fresh-pressed pineapple juice; freshly grated whole nutmeg. Economical: Pusser's Blue Label remains the canonical and economical choice (the trademark precludes substitutes if you're calling it a Painkiller); Coco Real or generic cream of coconut; canned Dole pineapple juice in a pinch.

Instructions

In a shaker combine fresh pineapple juice, fresh orange juice, cream of coconut, and Pusser's Navy rum.
Shake well with ice, then pour unstrained into a double old-fashioned glass or tiki mug.
Top with freshly grated nutmeg.
Garnish with an orange wheel and a maraschino cherry.

Sources

Pusser's Rum, "Pusser's Painkiller." https://pussersrum.com/blogs/cocktails/pussers-painkiller (accessed 2026-05-03), Pusser's official recipe and origin narrative, source for the trademarked 4-1-1-1 spec and the Charles Tobias reverse-engineering story; cited with the standard brand-promotional caveat. ↩
Mustipher, Tiki: Modern Tropical Cocktails (2019), Painkiller entry, Caribbean-roots scholar treatment of the drink's BVI / Soggy Dollar origin and Daphne Henderson's role at the bar. ↩
"Painkiller (cocktail)." Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Painkiller_(cocktail) (accessed 2026-05-03), documents the alternate George and Marie Myrick attribution and the original Cruzan-rum base, complicating the Pusser's-only trademark narrative. ↩